trailer:
Moria spends a lot of time discussing Card's views against gay marriage, says the film "ends up better on screen than one expected before sitting down to watch" and concludes: "It works reasonably well as an illustrated version of the book for those who have read it. On the other hand, I have my doubts whether anybody who comes to it as a film without reading the book is going to become a rabid fan." SF Signal gives it 1 1/2 out of 5 stars and finds much to criticize. Empire Online gives it 2 out of 5 stars and closes with this: "It admirably avoids many of the pitfalls of adapting this book, but seems to have lost some of the life and pace as well." Slate closes by saying, "I can understand wanting to skip Ender’s Game as a matter of moral principle [because of author Card's anti-gay activism], but you can also feel free to blow it off just because it’s not that good." EW gives it a C+ and calls it "oddly lifeless and emotionally unaffecting". Roger Ebert's site doesn't like it. Rotten Tomatoes has a 60% critics score.
Heck, I never read the book(s) and I liked it...might even become a fan. I'll give it more than 1.5 stars!
ReplyDelete-- A Pal
Sometimes I think film reviewers haven't watched the same film I have ;)
DeleteI have heard of Ender's Game, but had no idea it had all those big name artists in it. However, if it's an anti-gay film, I probably wouldn't like it. Although I am straight, I believe in standing up for anyone who gets picked on. Thanks for sharing this review. Sounds like you enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteIt is in no way an anti-gay film. The controversy is about Orson Scott Card's anti-gay activism. He is a Mormon and is outspoken on his views on gay marriage. There are those who won't read his works (or see movies based on them) because of this. The controversy over Card has re-emerged since he was chosen as a Superman writer by DC comics. There's an overview/timeline of the issues here: .http://www.vulture.com/2013/10/primer-orson-scott-card-enders-game-controversy.html
Delete